SMALL PHONE
PHONE
TABLET
DESKTOP
LARGE DESKTOP
XL DESKTOP
Nick Cafaro headshot

Nick Cafaro

Account Executive

phone icon for hortica614-687-1009
Contact Nick

Serves:
Ohio
Indiana

About Nick Cafaro

In my experience, it’s the people and problem-solving that make working in the insurance industry enjoyable. I’m invested in each of my clients. I’ll take time to learn your story, walk your property, and help you build coverage that works best for you.

With our industry-specific solutions, experienced support, and reliable protection, we strive to give you peace of mind while insuring your business.

When I’m not working, you’ll find me on the golf course, watching the New York Giants and Ohio State Buckeyes, or outdoors with my family.

“At Hortica, we understand that your business is as unique as the products you grow. With us, you’re never just a policyholder.”

Why work with Hortica?

Our associates are insurance professionals who understand the unique risks and trends of the industry and how they can impact your business. Together, we'll get to know your business and provide superior, cost-effective insurance solutions. That knowledge also helps us customize your coverage options and risk management opportunities.

We know your industry just like we know business insurance:

  • More than 135 years of protecting horticulture companies

  • Personable agents to guide you and provide customized insurance solutions

  • Insurance products designed for the horticulture and floral industries

1887
Since 1887, we've helped protect the horticultural industry.
We understand how your business is different and tailor our coverages to suit you.
A+ rating
Backed by Sentry Insurance, rated A+ (superior) by AM Best.*
Our financial stability gives you peace of mind.
$13.2B
The total insured value** of all property we help protect across the United States.
We're ready to help care for your unique business.
**February 2025

Our customers' stories

“We could get an insurance representative who knows business. But they don't know our business. That's where Hortica really steps in and makes such a difference in our business and our industry.”
Michelle Castellano, Vice President
Mellano & Company

A few of our products

Rows of plants in a greenhouse

Greenhouse insurance

We can help protect your greenhouse structures, crops, and machinery.

Learn more about greenhouse insurance
Flowers on a shelf

Garden center insurance

We have coverages to help protect your business property—and your business. Property and liability coverage are just the start.

Learn more about garden center insurance
Rows of flowers

Insurance for retail/wholesale/event florists

You have to keep track of everything at your shop—inventory, equipment, customers, and employees. Let us help with insurance coverage.

Learn more about florist insurance
Flowers around a document with a green magnifying glass

Need horticultural business insurance now?

Talk with our knowledgeable representatives and they’ll help you find the right coverage options for your business.

Request a quote

Still have questions?

Our customer page has more information and answers to some of the most frequently asked horticultural insurance questions we get. For an answer to a specific question, just fill out the form below with your information.

Phone